The debate over whether women should be allowed to breastfeed in public continues into 2023. While opinions differ, it’s clear that summer heat makes it difficult for mothers to stay covered while feeding their children. Simply put, it’s too hot for both mother and baby, and women should feel comfortable nursing wherever they are when their child is hungry.

Breastfeeding is a natural, vital part of a child’s growth and development, providing both nutrition and a chance for bonding. Regardless of public opinion, a mother has the right to breastfeed when she chooses, though some find it uncomfortable.

In 2018, Melanie Dudley was dining with her friends and her three-month-old son in a restaurant at 86°F when her baby needed to nurse. As she discreetly pulled out her nipple, a man at a nearby table asked her to cover up. Although Melanie was willing to be discreet, the heat made it difficult. “It was 95 degrees, and my baby was sweating,” she told TODAY. She decided to remove the cover and nurse freely.

The man, uncomfortable with the situation, was met with Melanie’s unexpected response—she covered her head with the cover instead, prompting laughter from the entire restaurant. “It wasn’t a fight, I just didn’t know what to say, so I covered my head,” Melanie explained.

A photo of this moment was shared on Facebook, quickly going viral with over 225,000 shares. Many people praised Melanie for her boldness. While she wasn’t the first to face criticism for nursing in public, her humorous response sparked a renewed conversation, even attracting media coverage.

Despite the incident being from 2018, the debate over public breastfeeding still stirs emotions today. It’s a mother’s right to breastfeed, yet women continue to face criticism for doing what is natural.