On May 8, 2025, white smoke rose above the Sistine Chapel, marking a historic moment as Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, a 69-year-old Chicago native, was elected Pope Leo XIV—the first American pontiff in Catholic Church history. In his first address, he offered a message of peace and humility, echoing the inclusive tone of his predecessor, Pope Francis. While many celebrated, the announcement drew immediate backlash from some right-wing figures in the U.S.

Though Leo XIV is seen as doctrinally conservative, his emphasis on cultural sensitivity, social justice, and climate action has drawn criticism from Trump-aligned commentators. Accusations of him being “woke” and “liberal” quickly surfaced online, citing his past critiques of U.S. immigration policy and his defense of universal compassion. Trump himself offered congratulations, but many MAGA supporters were far less welcoming.

Born and raised in a devout immigrant family, Pope Leo spent decades serving in Peru, gaining dual citizenship and building a reputation for humility, service, and moral clarity. His papacy is expected to continue Francis’ vision, with a distinct American and global pastoral touch. His election, though swift, surprised even his family, who described him as both honored and stunned.

As Pope Leo XIV steps into the global spotlight, he inherits not only the spiritual leadership of 1.3 billion Catholics, but also the scrutiny of a deeply polarized political world. His message, however, remains clear: peace without conditions, leadership rooted in integrity, and a Church open to dialogue—regardless of the critics.