MusicFlow · Soulful Tunes

Cade Mower’s Post Reopens The Voice Debate Over Night 2 Song Choices

Share Facebook X

After his elimination from The Voice Season 30, Cade Mower shared that his first choice for Y2K Night had not been approved. The revelation added a specific point to a wider discussion among viewers about whether the songs selected for Night 2 suited the singers competing on the live show.

Mower, who was on Team Riley, was eliminated alongside Team Kelly’s Anna McElroy in the November 16 episode. In a post afterward, he said he had wanted to perform Johnny Cash’s version of Nine Inch Nails’ “Hurt,” but that the choice was rejected because it did not fit the Y2K theme.

The Voice' Reveals the Top 10
The Voice' Reveals the Top 10

The post did not directly blame the show for his elimination. Mower also thanked people who supported him, expressed gratitude for the experience and the people he met or reconnected with, and said he was glad to be returning home to his family.

Song choices under scrutiny

Viewers had already been debating whether some of the night’s selections matched the performers’ voices or gave them the best opportunity to show their abilities. Mower’s disclosure prompted some commenters to wonder whether a different song might have changed his result. Others focused on the Y2K theme itself or said the backing band sometimes overpowered his vocals.

McElroy’s performance of Faith Hill’s “Breathe” also drew mixed responses. While some viewers praised her, others said the song was not a good fit for her voice. The differing reactions point to a broader disagreement over how much song selection shaped the Night 2 performances and eliminations—not to a claim by Mower that the show caused his departure.

With the Top 10 set, the competition is moving on to Dolly Parton Tribute Night, scheduled for November 23. The discussion following Night 2, however, has centered on whether the performers were given songs that worked for them, and what Mower’s account of his original choice adds to that debate.